Follow Us
twittergoogle_pluslinkedinrssyoutube
Subscribe to the BT Currents Blog

By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Recent Posts
The Legal Stuff
BT Currents - Hot Topics in Employment Law
0 0

24 Apr 2013 Testing the Supreme Court (again) on Retaliation Claims

Today, (Wed., April 24th), the Supreme Court hears oral argument in a closely watched employment retaliation case from the Fifth Circuit: University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center v. Nassar (U.S. No. 12-484). The ruling in this case, whatever the outcome, is likely to significantly impact employers and their ability to defend themselves against the ever-increasing number of retaliation claims. Here is a quick overview of the issues at hand. The central question in the Nassar case is what is the appropriate standard of proof for…

READ MORE
0 0

24 Apr 2013 Inconsistent Treatment Of Employees Gets You Every Time

Although you might think that cussing in the workplace should get an employee fired, a recent decision from the District of Colorado shows that it all comes down to the context. The court denied summary judgment for an employer, finding that the plaintiff-employee had established a prima face case of age discrimination and provided sufficient evidence of pretext. The case, Roach v. Safeway, Inc., Case No. 12-cv-1239-RBJ, involved a 60-year old store manager with 40 years of seniority in the company. The employee had an overall…

READ MORE
0 0

05 Apr 2013 D.C. District Court Finds That OFCCP Requirements Extend to Hospitals with HMOs

The federal district court for the District of Columbia recently ruled that three hospitals were deemed to be subcontractors and subject to the Office of Federal Contract Compliance Program’s (OFCCP) jurisdiction and reporting requirements because of the hospitals’ contractual relationships with an HMO. As a result, the district court held that the hospitals were subject to the EEO and affirmative action requirements of an Executive Order 11246, the Rehab Act and VEVRAA. In UPMC Braddock v Harris, the three hospitals subcontracted with UPMC Health Plan…

READ MORE
0 0

02 Apr 2013 Seventh Circuit Finds Menial Tasks, Isolation, and Allegations of Violence Provide Pipeline to Jury Trial

In reversing a district court’s grant of summary judgment on an employee’s hostile work environment claim under Title VII, the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit found a female plumber to have alleged sufficient facts to make it to a jury trial. Specifically, in Hall v. City of Chicago, found here, the only female plumber working within a particular division for the City of Chicago, alleged, among other things, that she was forced to do menial tasks (e.g., sorting of the exact same documents…

READ MORE
0 0

02 Apr 2013 U.S. Supreme Court to Consider Application of ADEA to State and Local Workers

The U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to hear an appeal from Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan on the issue of whether state and local government employees can bypass the Age Discrimination in Employment Act and sue for age discrimination under an equal protection theory. The case is Madigan v. Levin, Docket Number 12-872. Appellate courts are split on whether the ADEA is the exclusive route for state and local government employees to bring a claim for age discrimination, or whether an equal protection claim via…

READ MORE
0 0

01 Apr 2013 Increasing Discrimination Obligations Coming from State and Municipal Levels

In this recent Metropreneur Columbus article, I talked about the long term trend for forms of discrimination to only increase.  Rarely since the passage of Title VII in 1964 has a cause of action for discrimination been taken away.  As discussed more in the article, current manifestations of this long term trend include laws at various levels to protect employees against discrimination on the basis of their sexual orientation or identity, or on the basis of their unemployed status. Many of these particular initiatives are on the…

READ MORE
0 0

18 Mar 2013 Employee Retaliation Claims: Will the Supreme Court Stem the Tide?

It was no surprise for practitioners and their clients alike to learn that, statistically, retaliation claims remain the largest number of claims brought before the EEOC (in 2012, almost 38,000 charges alleged retaliation—38.1% of all charges). Worse, retaliation claims are expensive to defend. This point is painfully highlighted in this week’s submissions with the U.S. Supreme Court. Last week, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce (along with the Retail Litigation Center) filed with the Supreme Court an amici curiae brief in a case in which retaliation…

READ MORE
0 0

15 Mar 2013 Did They Just Say That? A Reminder That Off-The-Cuff Remarks Handcuff Employers in Employment Lawsuits

A recent race discrimination and retaliation case in Pennsylvania underscores the risks of off-the-cuff remarks by managers.  The case in the Middle District of Pennsylvania, Johnson v. Hershey Creamery Corp., No. 1:11-cv-00776 (M.D. Pa. Mar. 8, 2013), involved an African-American who worked as a seasonal employee for Hershey Creamery.  At the end of each season, the employee was laid off.  One year, two of his Caucasian co-workers were hired as full-time, regular employees.  When he asked why he was not hired, Hershey told him that…

READ MORE
0 0

15 Mar 2013 Some Basic Advice as “March Madness” Begins

It’s mid-March. That – as any fan of college basketball knows – means that the NCAA basketball tournament and “March Madness” are about to begin. As a result, a case that was handed down by the U.S Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit yesterday is timely.  In Covington v. International Association of Approved Basketball Officials, No. 11-3096, 2013 WL 979067 (3d Cir. Mar. 14, 2013), a female referee alleged that the organization that supplies referees for high school basketball games in New Jersey’s Hamilton…

READ MORE
0 0

08 Mar 2013 Internal Investigations Can Be Crucial to Defense Against Retaliation Claims

It will come as no surprise to many employers that retaliation charges under Title VII and similar employment laws are, in many instances, more challenging to prevent and defend than discrimination claims. So there is comfort to be found in a pair of rulings from the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals today, affirming that an employer’s investigation into alleged workplace misconduct can serve to stave off liability in the event of a retaliation lawsuit. In Vaughn v. Vilsack, the Court affirmed summary judgment for the…

READ MORE